By Aqib Javed Cheema, Principal Solicitor-Advocate, Harvard Defence Lawyers
The brief of evidence lands on the table. Hundreds of pages of police intelligence. Months of telephone intercepts. Photographs taken by undercover officers. Your own words, played back to you in an interview room.
And someone, somewhere, has told you: “It’s an overwhelming case. Your best option is to plead guilty.”
At Harvard Defence Lawyers, we hear that sentence often. We have also repeatedly shown that it is wrong. A conspiracy case that looks overwhelming on paper is still only a prosecution case, and the Crown must prove every element beyond reasonable doubt. Volume of material is not the same as proof.
What is a conspiracy charge in NSW?
Conspiracy is, at its heart, a charge about an agreement. No drugs need to change hands, no weapon needs to be fired and no fraud needs to be completed. The allegation is that two or more people agreed to commit an offence, and that each intended it to be carried out.
Conspiracy can arise in several ways:
- Common law conspiracy under NSW law, including conspiracy to commit a wide range of indictable offences.
- Statutory conspiracy offences, such as conspiracy to murder (Crimes Act 1900 (NSW)) and conspiracy to commit offences under the Drug Misuse and Trafficking Act 1985 (NSW), which carry the same penalty as the offence the parties are said to have agreed to commit.
- Commonwealth conspiracy under section 11.5 of the Criminal Code (Cth), often used in serious drug importation and organised crime matters. The Commonwealth offence also requires that at least one party committed an overt act in pursuit of the agreement.
Because the offence is the agreement itself, prosecutors build conspiracy cases from layers of circumstantial material. That is exactly why they can be challenged layer by layer.
The evidence that makes people panic
1. Police intelligence
Intelligence reports, informant material and analyst summaries can create a powerful picture of a “network”. But intelligence is not evidence. Much of it is hearsay, opinion or inference that may never be admissible in a trial. Where police rely on it to obtain warrants, the validity of those warrants and the accuracy of the material put before an issuing authority can be scrutinised. Where the Crown resists disclosure, issues of public interest immunity arise and we test them.
2. Telephone intercepts
Intercepted calls feel devastating, because they are your client’s own voice. But interception is tightly regulated under the Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979 (Cth) and its NSW counterpart. Questions we examine include:
- Was the warrant validly obtained and executed, and was the interception lawful?
- Who is actually speaking? Voice identification is frequently disputed.
- What do the words really mean? Conversations between friends, family or colleagues are often vague, joking, boastful or about something entirely lawful. Police “translations” of supposed coded language are opinion, and opinion can be challenged.
- Is the transcript accurate? Transcripts are only an aid to the recording, and errors and omissions, especially in translated calls, matter.
- Does the conversation prove an agreement, or only knowledge, association or talk?
If evidence was obtained improperly or illegally, the court has the power to exclude it under section 138 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW).
3. Admissions, direct or indirect
Admissions are among the most persuasive things a jury can hear, which is why the law surrounds them with safeguards. In NSW:
- Admissions made to police in relation to an indictable offence generally need to be electronically recorded to be admissible (Criminal Procedure Act 1986, s 281).
- The court can exclude admissions that are unreliable, or that were obtained in circumstances making them likely to be unreliable (Evidence Act, ss 85 and 90).
- Offhand remarks, “indirect” admissions, and comments made to undercover operatives are open to challenge on context, reliability and fairness.
- Statements by co-accused are not automatically evidence against our client, and they carry their own limits and directions.
A statement that sounds like an admission in a headline can look very different once it is placed in full context.
4. Undercover operations and photographic surveillance
Undercover work and covert photography usually raise two questions: was it lawful, and what does it actually prove? Controlled operations must be authorised and conducted within the Law Enforcement (Controlled Operations) Act 1997 (NSW) or the Commonwealth equivalent, and surveillance devices are regulated by the Surveillance Devices Act 2007 (NSW). Where police conduct crosses the line, the court can exclude the evidence or, in appropriate cases, stay the proceedings.
And even where surveillance is lawful, a photograph of two people meeting is not an agreement to commit a crime. Pictures show what happened. They do not show what was intended.
Defences and strategies to a conspiracy charge
No two cases are the same, but the defence toolkit in NSW conspiracy matters often includes:
1. No agreement. Association, presence, friendship or even knowledge of another person’s activity is not the same as agreeing to commit an offence.
2. No intention. The Crown must prove our client intended the offence to be carried out, not merely that they talked about it, joked about it or went along with a conversation.
3. Challenging identification. Voices, faces, phones, vehicles and addresses all have to be linked to the accused by admissible evidence.
4. Excluding or limiting evidence. Unlawful interception, defective warrants, unrecorded or unreliable admissions, and improperly obtained surveillance can all be challenged.
5. Withdrawal. Under the Commonwealth regime, a person who genuinely withdrew from the agreement before the offence and took reasonable steps to prevent it may have a defence.
6. Attacking the Crown’s inferences. In circumstantial cases the Crown must show guilt is the only reasonable inference. If an innocent explanation is open, the jury must acquit.
7. Credibility and reliability of witnesses. Informants, co-offenders and cooperating witnesses often have powerful reasons to shade the truth.
8. Disclosure and procedural fairness. Late, partial or missing material can change the shape of a trial.
Even where a trial is not the right path, a strong challenge to the evidence can significantly improve negotiations on the charge, the facts and ultimately the sentence.
“Overwhelming” is an opinion, not a verdict
We have defended clients in conspiracy matters where other lawyers described the case as “overwhelming”. These cases carry long brief-of-evidence volumes, heavy intelligence, intercepts and surveillance, and yet they were still defensible. The difference lies in rigorous preparation: reading every page, listening to every call, testing every warrant, mapping every inference, and not accepting the Crown’s narrative at face value.
Pleading guilty is a choice. It should never be a reflex driven by the size of a brief. Every accused person has the right to put the Crown to its proof, and a defence strategy should be built on the evidence, not on fear.
If you have been charged, or think you may be
- Do not speak to police without legal advice. You have the right to remain silent, and anything you say can be used.
- Do not discuss the matter on the phone or in messages. Assume everything is recorded.
- Do not contact co-accused or witnesses.
- Get advice early. The best opportunities to challenge evidence and shape a case often come before charges are finalised.
arvard Defence Lawyers is a Sydney criminal defence firm practising exclusively in criminal law, with offices in Blacktown, Liverpool/Belmore and the Sydney CBD. We offer 24/7 client contact and fixed-fee representation, so you know where you stand from the start.
Call us any time, day or night. Visit harvarddefencelawyers.com.au.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.




